Finally! A big name company (HP) gets it...in a good way.
Yesterday a blogmiga forwarded me an Evite she had received inviting Silicon Valley/Bay Area bloggers to a Hewlett-Packard blogging event scheduled in California on September 29th. When I looked at the Evite I saw a couple of things that concerned me:1. The date of the event. The first night of Rosh Hashanah is September 29th and the event was scheduled to begin at 6:30PM.
2. The contact information for BSM Media* at the bottom of the Evite; The same external consultancy Disney had hired last Spring to coordinate their blogger event which had been scheduled on Passover.
Admittedly I rolled my eyes and heaved a sigh. I knew I wasn't going to contact the external consultant named on the Evite because she wasted my time in April and lied to me. A lot. And no, I did not confuse what she told me with stretching the truth so let's leave it at that and move on...
I googled the name of the HP contact on the Evite in California. I picked up the phone and called. Hoping not to be dismissed with a "Sorry you weren't invited. It's a personal decision everyone invited must make for themselves. If the event was held on {Insert Major Christian Holiday} I just wouldn't attend. You just need to figure out what is best for you. I'm sorry your feelings are hurt. But you know what? There is one Jew coming to the event and that Jew said it was okay." Every time I hear that bullshit response, and I've heard it plenty, I scream in my head, "This is a business function, not a family bar mitzvah. It's not personal, it's professional. Why don't you grow some? Own the scheduling mistake, apologize, postpone the event and move on!" Expecting the worst, but hoping for the best, I left a message expressing my concern about the event scheduled on Rosh Hashanah and ended with my call back number.
Karen Cage from HP returned my call and apologized. The kind of no excuse apology which can only be described with the word genuine. The only kind of apology that actually means something and is worth making. Karen hit one out of the ballpark for herself as well as HP.
Karen Cage from HP returned my call and apologized. The kind of no excuse apology which can only be described with the word genuine. The only kind of apology that actually means something and is worth making. Karen hit one out of the ballpark for herself as well as HP.
We had a very positive conversation. She explained the event had been originally planned for the prior week, but another event would have conflicted so HP had to make new arrangements very quickly. In the haste to reschedule, she hadn't realized the new date is Rosh Hashanah. She also told me Rosh Hashanah wasn't on the calender she was using which contributed to the mistake being made. Certainly I understand both of these things. Calenders aren't perfect, neither are human beings. Mistakes happen.
Karen further explained it was HP, and not the external consultant, who planned this event. Of course it was then my turn to apologize for any incorrect conclusion I had made about their external consultant. (However, I maintain it is a consultant's role, when coordinating an event on the behalf of a client, to double check the date to determine it is indeed clean and clear. So the external consultant isn't off the hook entirely on this one. Why? Because I believe if your company name is on the Evite, then your company is responsible for the mistake. 'nuff said.)
We then moved ahead to the "What now?" Karen said it might be very expensive to postpone or cancel the event but she would bring the suggestion back to the team at HP. I shared with Karen just what I tell myself and my kids, "Some mistakes are expensive. I've made some costly ones myself. We all do." I also shared with Karen a mantra I repeat to myself and my kids, "You can't put a price on integrity and doing the right thing. You just can't." I made the suggestion HP eat the cost and take the only appropriate action; Postpone the event.
However, a flip side could be considered; HP policy. Knowing I don't work at HP, certainly it may be policy the company doesn't acknowledge any holidays when planning functions. After all, our son's preschool in Illinois was holiday free, only acknowledging birthdays. So I said to Karen, "If HP commonly holds business functions on other major religious holidays, and doing so would be consistent with HP policy, then by all means, have at it." I am a big fan of being consistent, both at home and away.
Karen and I concluded our conversation as I shared my hope HP would make a stand in corporate America by postponing the event and in turn sending a powerful message that HP values and respects all of its customers and employees. Not some more than others. Everyone counts. Everyone matters. Equally.
Karen called me back last night. HP chose to postpone the event. Thank you HP for stepping up and making the best decision ever.
Do you know what this really means? Do you? Wait for it...
Now that HP has come to me asking forgiveness, seeking reconciliation and I have granted them atonement, we all have one less sin to worry about on Yom Kippur!
Can I get an, "Amen!"?
*Edited to add: BSM Media is headquartered in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Fort Lauderdale is in Broward County, Florida. According to the Jewish Data Bank website:
Broward County is estimated to be the 4th largest Jewish community in the United States of America.
Edited to add: In response to a post written on BSM Media's site please note: My statements in this post are factual. I have the proof and I am willing to provide it.
Labels: Corporate Responsibility, Hewlett Packard, Rosh Hashanah
















14 Comments:
Devra, I continue to appreciate you more and more...because consistency and me, we're like this. ; ) (Seriously, it's a huge deal with me and a lot of people don't get it.)
I'm glad they changed it. HP impressed me couple years ago at BlogHer Biz. Maybe corporate ethos works occasionally?
Hope you get to go when it's reschedulued.
Good for them, and I'm a little sad we traded in our HP for a Cannon.
L'Shana Tova.
Laurie,
Thank you for the kind words. And yeah,I think sometimes corporate ethos does work. And I hope this situation gets other corporations thinking about working their ethos more often! ; )
I won't need to go when it's rescheduled. It's for local bloggers in California. I'm about 2500 miles East of "local." LOL
Well Jodi, at least you aren't feeling guilty about it! ; )
You kick ass. That is all.
Another small victory for those who dare to believe that some people out there still care to do the right thing, even if it makes their own world imperfect. Way to go Devra and HP!
Next time I need someone to make that kind of call, I'm calling you first! ;)
corporate irrisponsibility or lack of religious understanding? Sheesh.
We're really glad things got straightened out!
Good for HP, doing the right think, though I won't hold out hope that it will be an "example" for other companies. In this day and age, ethics and business no longer seem to go hand in hand.
I also agree that it does not take the consultant off the hook, simply because HP chose the date. Exactly what are these people "consulting?" They are supposed to be there to arrange everything and to make sure the event goes off "without a hitch." Well, placing it on a holiday, is certainly a big hitch.
The only thing I will say about the flip side of the argument about whether they would do such a thing on a "Christian holiday" is that, for right or wrong (it is a whole other debate), many of those holidays have also become "Federal Holidays" or as they used to be known, "Bank Holidays" and as such are days that are viewed as holidays beyond the religious realm, and get the same assumptions of "nobody being around to conduct business" as non-religious holidays such as Independence Day or Labor Day. To that end, I think it is far less nefarious (not any less wrong mind you, just not ill-intended) that these companies schedule events on these holidays, because they are just as quick to schedule events on religious holidays such as All Saints Day or other Christian religious but not "bank" holidays.
Either way, it is nice to see, at a time where business sees people as nothing more than expenses (employess) or dollar signs (customers), that at least one can step and do the right thing once in a while.
Am in the process of picking a new scanner. Was between 2. Guess which one I picked after reading this? Thanks Devra for saying something and thanks HP for listening!
Whoo HP! My next printer is going to be an HP for sure. I love companies with cool people behind cool products.
Way to go for pursuing this so professionally Devra.
Wow, Devra. This tale of corporate responsiveness and sensitivity warmed my heart.
There is a publication called Chase's Calendar, which is kind of an almanac of every holiday and proclamation (you know, National Safety Week) on the books. With a country that is so diversified, I think it would be a small investment for corporate event planners, so they don't inadvertently schedule an important event on Rosh Hashanah - or Dinali, or Eid, or Tet or any of the other religious holidays that they may be asking their attendees to disregard.
I'm so glad that you had such a productive conversation with HP and they really listened to you. Victory!
Post a Comment
<< Home